Reporters vs. publishers and editors: On IQs, faulty edits, a Knopf editor and an unnamed columnist
The Solomon Scandals is a reporter’s novel, with editors and the publisher in the way of truth and decency.
If nothing else, an ideological chasm gapes in the newspaper business between editorial coolies and publishers. Reporters tend to be far, far more liberal at many dailies than are the publishers. So what to make of a new study saying that liberals as a group are smarter? Time for reporters to take over and rescue the industry? Should publisher Katharine Weymouth (photo) at the Washington Post bring back Nicholas “Left at the Post” von Hoffman as her replacement?
Outside the newspaper business, I’ll note a Gawker writer’s assault on Knopf or at least one of the editors there who failed to edit her own copy. Exactly. Didn’t I tell you? Writers are smarter.
Confession: Underneath I do have a soft spot for editors and publishers, or at least those at my old newspaper who tolerated me. I sold my Web site partly because I lacked the resources for the copy editors I wanted to hire, and I wouldn’t mind some here. The right editor speaking up could have saved a certain Washington columnist—I’ve mentioned her name enough for the moment—from lots of pain, a point I’ve made here before. I was pleased to learn of similar sentiments held by the Post’s Gene Weingarten.
You might also enjoy:- Bible of newspaper biz reincarnated under new owner, Duncan McIntosh
- Truth or PR spin? W. Post’s Dana Milbank fires back at TNR’s ‘Apocalypse’ analysis of L Street
- Solomon Scandals hyperlocal series so far: A list for latecomers
- The essential copy editor
- ‘I write like William Shakespeare’: Paste ‘The Solomon Scandals’ into this Web form and see for yourself
Fisticuff in the Washington Post’s newsroom: And here you thought ‘Scandals’ was only a NOVEL?
Henry Allen, a Pulitzer Prize winner in his late 60s, punched the face of feature writer Manuel Roig-Franzia—right there in the city room at the Washington Post.
Marcus Brauchli, the Post’s executive editor, is said to have separated Allen, an ex-Marine, from Roig-Franzia. Enjoy not-quite-ringside reports from The Washingtonian’s Harry Jaffe, FishBowlDC’s Matt Dornic, the Politico’s Michael Calderone, the Washington City Paper’s Erik Wemple and the Post’s own Gene Weingarten, as well as Huffington Post commentary.
You might also enjoy:- Wash. Post killing off domestic news bureaus: D.C. ‘prism’ better than the full story?
- Solomon Scandals hyperlocal series so far: A list for latecomers
- Free paper copy of ‘The Solomon Scandals’ if you come up with the best replacement for ‘L Street’ and ‘WaPo’
- The Watergate editor and the society legend: A loving look at them by their son who lives ‘A Different Life’
- Georgetown Dish joins TBD blog network: Deju vu angles—in Washington Post’s backyard
Buying info and other basics
Vis-à-vis real life
Newest comments
David Rothman on TBD hyperlocal site’s traffic pops up during hostage crisis at Discovery Channel’s headquarters
Steve Buttry on TBD hyperlocal site’s traffic pops up during hostage crisis at Discovery Channel’s headquarters
Ornette on Sally Quinn, snobbery and the Mink Stole Ladies Syndrome
Recent Posts
- TBD hyperlocal site’s traffic pops up during hostage crisis at Discovery Channel’s headquarters
- The Solomon Scandals novel vs. online gossip about Skyline Towers and the intel community
- The decline—and future promise—of investigative journalism
- The Solomon Scandals’ bureaucratic setting—a few decades later
- A guide to the Solomon Scandals site
